*This AI-generated summary is based on reporting by TaiwanPlus and verified by newsroom fact checkers. Learn more about our policy here.
Battle for Pennsylvania: Trump’s Jobs Pledge Faces Skepticism in Key Swing State
Bethlehem, Pennsylvania — Presidential candidate Donald Trump has reignited his pledge to "steal jobs back from China" and restore Pennsylvania’s manufacturing industry to its former glory. But in this critical swing state, the response to his promises has been deeply mixed, reflecting the challenges of reviving an economy shaped by industrial decline.
For retired steamfitter John Kostick, being a supporter of Democratic candidate Kamala Harris hasn’t been easy. In his hometown, Kostick says his Harris campaign signs are routinely replaced with those supporting Trump. Despite the Republican candidate’s renewed vow to bring back manufacturing jobs, Kostick remains unconvinced.
“Donald Trump’s whole candidacy is built on lies,” Kostick said. “He said he was going to help coal miners. Did he help the coal miners? No. Coal miners still lost their jobs.”
Trump’s 2024 campaign has doubled down on the message that first swept him to office in 2016, promising to restore Pennsylvania to its industrial heyday. Speaking at a rally in the state, Trump claimed he would reclaim jobs lost to foreign competition, particularly from China.
The Legacy of Bethlehem Steel
Nowhere is the weight of those promises more visible than in Bethlehem, once home to the world’s second-largest steel manufacturer. At its peak, Bethlehem Steel employed 35,000 people, driving much of the local economy. The mill shut down production more than 30 years ago, however, forcing the city to pivot toward industries like medical devices, pharmaceuticals and finance.
A former Bethlehem mayor, Don Cunningham, now CEO of the Lehigh Valley Economic Development Corporation, argues that the idea of reviving the steel industry is little more than nostalgia.
“It’s a romantic notion that people love to hear,” Cunningham said. “It’s like if somebody said you can go back to childhood and be in your safe space with your mom and dad. It’s a nice notion, but it’s not an economic strategy.”
Diverging Views on Trump’s Promise
The city’s industrial legacy remains a point of pride, with former steelworker Don Young leading tours of the now defunct mill. While he is a Republican, his enthusiasm for Trump is mild compared to that of his wife Barbara, a retired lab technician who believes Trump’s policies are essential for America’s independence.
“We need to be independent of China and we need to frack and dig for our own coal,” Barbara Young said, while wearing a Trump hat. “My father and grandfathers worked in the coal mines. It’s a hard job but it’s necessary for America’s security.”
The Stakes in Pennsylvania
With both Harris and Trump campaigning heavily in Pennsylvania, the state has become a microcosm of the national debate over economic recovery and global competition. Harris has likewise vowed to counter China’s influence and support American workers, but her approach emphasizes modernizing the economy rather than returning to the past.
As Pennsylvania grapples with the ghosts of its industrial history, its voters face a stark choice: embrace Trump’s promises of revival or Harris’s vision of renewal. The outcome here could determine the presidency, making Pennsylvania arguably the most crucial battleground in this election.
03:23
00:42
00:48
00:40
02:56
03:24
00:30
02:36
00:23
00:33
03:09
04:06
00:39
00:36
00:25
00:22